Edison Park Commission approves controversial mural on historic property despite ongoing disputes

The Fort Myers Historic Preservation Commission made headlines during its December 19, 2024 meeting by approving a controversial mural in the Edison Park Historic District. The mural, which depicts oranges and orange blossoms, was painted on the side of a structure originally built in 1948. This approval came after the mural was already completed, leading to an "after the fact" review by the commission.

The discussion highlighted the complexities surrounding historic preservation and artistic expression. The applicant, Ashley Randall, who is both the homeowner and the artist, expressed frustration over being required to seek approval for artwork on what she claims is a non-contributing structure. Randall pointed out that documentation supports her claim, stating that her property does not contribute to the historic character of the district, as it was built after the 1945 cutoff established in the founding documents of Edison Park.

Commission members debated the implications of allowing murals in historic districts. While some members acknowledged the artistic merit of the mural, others raised concerns about setting a precedent for future murals and how they might affect the district's historic integrity. One member noted that the mural had grown on her over time, despite initial reservations about its appropriateness.

Ultimately, the commission unanimously approved the mural, citing compliance with local sign codes and the Secretary of Interior Standards for Rehabilitation. The decision reflects a balancing act between preserving historical character and embracing contemporary artistic expression in Fort Myers. The approval also raises questions about how the city will navigate similar requests in the future, as the line between historic preservation and personal expression continues to blur.