During a recent government meeting, passionate discussions emerged regarding proposed changes to spearfishing regulations in Utah, particularly concerning the potential impact on fish populations. Ben Allen, an avid sport fisherman, voiced his concerns during the public comment period, highlighting the risks posed by the new regulations to the state's broodstock and trophy fish populations.

Allen pointed out that while the number of spear fishermen in Utah is relatively small compared to the total licensed anglers, their practices could significantly affect the largest fish, which are often female and crucial for natural reproduction. He noted that recent records indicate a troubling trend, with nine out of thirteen new state records for warm water species being set in the last seven years, suggesting a preference among spear fishermen for targeting larger fish.

To mitigate these risks, Allen proposed specific restrictions: banning night spearfishing, which he argued gives an unfair advantage due to the use of artificial light, and closing spearfishing during the walleye spawning season from March 1 until the fourth Saturday in May in several key water bodies.

Greg Moore, another speaker, echoed Allen's sentiments, emphasizing the need for checks and balances in spearfishing practices. He expressed concern that the proposed regulations allowing night spearfishing could lead to the exploitation of vulnerable walleye populations during their spawning period.

The discussions reflect a growing concern among anglers about the sustainability of fish populations in Utah's waters, as stakeholders call for more stringent regulations to protect vital species from overfishing. The meeting underscored the importance of balancing recreational fishing practices with the ecological health of aquatic environments.