Concerns over a proposed biochar facility in Lake County took center stage during the Planning Commission meeting on December 12, 2024. Community members voiced strong objections, highlighting the facility's proximity to local schools and sensitive waterways, including Rodman Slough, which feeds into Clear Lake.

Residents pointed out that the map presented by Tom Jordan, a representative from Scotts Valley Energy Corporation, failed to accurately depict the facility's location relative to four nearby schools, including Upper Lake Middle School and Upper Lake High School. One speaker emphasized that only one property separates the proposed site from these educational institutions, raising alarms about potential environmental hazards.

The discussion intensified as community members expressed concerns about the facility's impact on local water quality. They noted that the area has the highest water table, meaning any spills could severely affect groundwater and the lake. Despite the assessment claiming no waterways were present, residents insisted that a waterway runs through the proposed site, particularly during the wet season.

Critics also questioned the validity of the data supporting the biochar production process, arguing that it relies on hypothetical scenarios rather than concrete evidence. They raised alarms about the types of biomass that could be used, including agricultural waste potentially contaminated with pesticides and municipal waste, which could pose additional health risks.

In response, Tom Jordan clarified that the site was chosen due to its minimal surrounding population, not to downplay potential impacts. He emphasized that the facility would not be harmful, countering the community's fears.

As public comments concluded, the urgency of the residents' concerns was clear. They urged the commission to reconsider the proposed location, advocating for a safer alternative that would protect the community, schools, and local waterways. The meeting underscored the ongoing tension between development and environmental stewardship in Lake County.