The Lake County Planning Commission meeting on December 12, 2024, focused on the proposed biochar production facility by Scotts Valley Energy Corporation, raising significant environmental and community concerns. Public comments highlighted the lack of concrete data on emissions and particulate levels from the facility, emphasizing that the environmental assessments conducted previously did not accurately reflect potential impacts.

Community members expressed worries about the types of biomass that could be used in the facility, which may include agricultural waste and municipal waste, potentially containing harmful chemicals. Questions were raised about oversight and monitoring of the biomass used, with residents fearing that the facility could shift from using woody biomass to more hazardous materials without proper regulation.

Concerns were also voiced regarding the facility's location near wildlife areas and schools. One speaker pointed out that the proposed six-foot fence could restrict wildlife access, while another urged the commission to consider the health and safety of local residents, schools, and waterways. The speaker referenced past projects by the Scotts Valley tribe that allegedly did not adequately assess environmental impacts.

In response, Tom Jordan from Scotts Valley Energy Corporation clarified that the facility would primarily process pure wood chips, asserting that the biochar produced would not be carcinogenic. He emphasized that the facility aims to create wood chips for other projects rather than focusing on biochar production. Jordan also addressed logistical concerns, stating that the facility would operate with minimal truck traffic, estimating two to five trucks per day.

The commission discussed the lease agreement for the facility, which is set for 15 years on prime agricultural land. It was noted that the land is part of the Middle Creek restoration project, and any future use would need to comply with restoration goals. The commission is expected to deliberate further on the proposal, weighing community concerns against the potential benefits of the facility.