In a recent government meeting, discussions centered around the proposed renovations for the historic Robert West House in St. Petersburg, Florida, which has faced significant deterioration over the years. The house, recognized for its unique architectural style and historic designation since 1995, has been plagued by water intrusion and mold issues, prompting the current owners, the Hartmans, to seek extensive repairs.

Initially, the renovation proposal included a complete replacement of the wood siding with polymer composite materials, which raised concerns among preservation staff regarding the use of substitute materials that do not visually match the historic elements. Staff emphasized the importance of retaining original materials wherever possible and recommended selective replacement rather than complete overhauls.

Following a review of the staff report, the applicants revised their proposal to focus on repairing damaged siding and trim using in-kind materials, replacing the roof with historically accurate five-volt crimp metal roofing, and addressing significant water damage caused by improper flashing around windows. The revisions aim to align the project with the design guidelines set forth by the preservation commission.

During the meeting, Michael McGrave, representing the homeowners, detailed the extensive damage discovered, including termite infestations and structural issues that rendered the house uninhabitable. He highlighted the urgency of the repairs to prevent further deterioration and potential safety hazards, such as exposed electrical wiring.

The commission ultimately recommended approval of the revised proposal, emphasizing the need for ongoing communication with staff to ensure that any significant replacements adhere to preservation standards. The goal remains to restore the Robert West House to a safe and livable condition while maintaining its historic character.