In a recent San Francisco Planning Commission meeting, discussions centered around a proposed residential project that aims to add density to the downtown area. The project, which involves constructing a new building with affordable housing units, has sparked a mix of support and concern among commissioners.

Commissioner Moore raised questions regarding the allocation of affordable units within the building, particularly those located in the below-grade basement. The project sponsor clarified that the affordable units would be assigned in compliance with the city's inclusionary housing procedures, which include a lottery system managed by the Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD). This process aims to ensure equitable distribution of affordable housing options throughout the building.

Further discussions highlighted the importance of maintaining proportionality in unit distribution, as outlined in a planning director bulletin. This guideline mandates that affordable units must be evenly distributed throughout the lower two-thirds of the building, preventing developers from clustering them in less desirable locations.

The meeting also touched on the aesthetic concerns regarding the project's height and design. Some commissioners expressed that the visual impact of the new building might be overstated, noting that existing structures in the area are not particularly attractive. Commissioner Moore emphasized the need for vibrancy in downtown San Francisco and the importance of increasing housing availability for various income levels.

Ultimately, the commission voted on the project, resulting in a narrow approval with a 4-3 vote. Commissioners Williams, Imperial, and Moore opposed the motion, citing concerns about the project's potential impact on neighboring properties and adherence to residential design guidelines. The project will now move forward, with further discussions scheduled for October 17, 2024, to address ongoing concerns and finalize details.