In a recent public hearing, the St. Paul City Council addressed a significant appeal concerning a rent increase at the Haven of Battle Creek, a residential property with reported habitability violations, including asbestos issues. The appellant, Samayyah Mohammed, expressed her frustration over the lengthy process that led her family to relocate, despite their desire to remain in St. Paul since 2007. Mohammed, alongside representatives from the Housing Justice Center, argued that the city’s Department of Safety and Inspections (DSI) had failed to adequately address their complaints regarding unsafe living conditions prior to approving the rent increase.

During the hearing, it was revealed that Mohammed had filed a complaint about asbestos violations in February 2023, before the appeal was granted. The representatives emphasized that the city has a legal obligation not to approve rent increases when habitability violations are present, citing specific ordinances that support their case. They urged the council to deny the rent increase based on the documented health and safety concerns.

Councilmember Johnson, who motioned to approve the appeal, highlighted the importance of differentiating between the council's recommendations and the legislative hearing officer's suggestions. She noted that the timeline of events indicated a failure on the city's part to act on known violations, which should have precluded any rent increase.

The council ultimately voted in favor of granting the appeal, with seven members supporting the motion and none opposed. This decision means that the proposed rent increase will not be imposed on the unit in question, reflecting the council's recognition of the ongoing habitability issues and the need for a more thorough review of the appeal process moving forward. The council's action underscores a commitment to tenant rights and the enforcement of housing safety regulations in St. Paul.