The City of Malibu's regular council meeting on August 26, 2024, highlighted significant concerns regarding city commission appointments and conduct, raising questions about governance and transparency.

A key discussion point centered on the eligibility of Joe Drummond, a member of the Public Works Commission. A resident raised allegations that Drummond is not a city resident, which could violate city ordinance 2.44.020 that mandates commission members be residents. The speaker urged the city attorney and council members to investigate the matter, suggesting that Drummond's votes could be invalidated and potentially expose the city to legal challenges. This prompted calls for her immediate removal from the commission.

Another topic of concern was the behavior of Planning Commission Chair John Matta. Residents criticized Matta for creating a dysfunctional environment during meetings, citing instances of rudeness and disrespect towards staff and applicants. Specific allegations included a breach of protocol where Matta allegedly discussed an agenda item with an external party during a meeting, raising potential violations of the Brown Act, which governs public meetings in California. The speaker emphasized that such actions undermine public trust and could be seen as intimidation tactics against residents who voice criticism.

Additionally, concerns were raised about the sharing of private information regarding council member Sam Kaplan's mortgage, allegedly disclosed by Mayor Stewart through city email. This raised questions about confidentiality and the handling of sensitive information within the council.

The meeting underscored the importance of adherence to city regulations and ethical conduct among council members and commission appointees. As discussions continue, the council faces pressure to address these issues to restore confidence among Malibu residents.