Residents of East Murphy Street voiced strong opposition to a proposed beer garden during a recent city council meeting, citing concerns over noise, parking, and the potential disruption to their neighborhood's character.

The meeting featured public comments from several local residents, including a heartfelt plea from a long-time homeowner whose family has lived in the area for over 150 years. She expressed fears that the beer garden, proposed by Perla Vareza, would transform the block into a bar scene, undermining the historical value and quality of life in the neighborhood.

Daniel Lester, another resident, echoed these sentiments, emphasizing the importance of peace and quiet in Alpine, which he described as a haven for families and retirees. He warned that the introduction of two bar establishments could lead to increased noise and parking issues, making it difficult for residents to access their homes.

Leonel Rodriguez, who lives just a block away from the proposed site, raised additional concerns regarding sanitation and the source of food being served at the beer garden. He questioned the safety of food prepared off-site and highlighted existing parking congestion in the area, which he feared would worsen with the new establishment. Rodriguez also inquired about the water supply for the beer garden and the safety measures in place for any fire pits.

The council meeting concluded public comments without immediate response from city officials, as the discussion moved into public hearings. The residents' concerns reflect a broader apprehension about maintaining the neighborhood's integrity amidst new commercial developments.