In a challenging start for the Middletown Bears, the Newburgh Goldbacks dominated the first quarter of their Thursday night football matchup, quickly establishing a commanding lead. After a brief offensive series that resulted in a 4-yard completion and an incomplete pass, Middletown faced a critical third down situation. However, a strong defensive play by Newburgh's Steven Jones halted their progress, leading to a three-and-out and forcing a punt from Kevon Scott.

The Goldbacks capitalized on the ensuing punt, with returner Liam Ehlers making a significant impact by returning the ball from the 45-yard line to the Middletown 5-yard line. This short field set up Newburgh for immediate scoring opportunities. Quarterback Montgomery took advantage, scoring two touchdowns in quick succession, including a 5-yard run that marked his third touchdown of the evening. With the extra point successfully converted by kicker Steiner, Newburgh surged ahead 21-0 with just 16 seconds remaining in the first quarter.

Middletown's defense, which had already been on the field for a limited time, faced the daunting task of regrouping as they prepared for their next offensive series. Despite their struggles, the Bears had shown resilience in previous games, notably nearly overcoming a 17-point deficit against Cornwall last week. As the game progressed, all eyes were on whether Middletown could find a way to respond to Newburgh's early onslaught.