In a recent Planning Commission meeting, a proposed residential development at 613 Wisconsin Street has sparked significant public opposition due to concerns over its scale, design, and potential impacts on the neighborhood. The project, which involves demolishing an existing two-bedroom home to construct a new four-story dwelling, has drawn criticism from multiple local residents who argue that the new structure would be out of character with the surrounding area.

The project, presented by owner Carrie Murphy Hogan and her husband Martin, aims to create a modern family home with three bedrooms and enhanced living space. The design includes a lower floor tucked into the hillside, which the developers argue will minimize its visual impact. However, several neighbors have voiced strong objections, claiming that the proposed height and mass of the building would overshadow existing homes and infringe on their privacy.

Public comments highlighted a range of concerns, including the potential for water intrusion affecting neighboring properties, the ecological impact of demolishing the existing structure, and the disruption caused by construction activities. Residents expressed fears that the new development would set a precedent for future projects that could further alter the character of the Potrero Hill neighborhood.

Opponents of the project, including long-time residents, emphasized the importance of maintaining the neighborhood's architectural harmony and the need for developments that respect existing residential guidelines. They argued that the proposed home would not only disrupt their quality of life but also contribute to the ongoing affordability crisis by adding another high-end property to an already expensive market.

The Planning Commission is set to deliberate on the conditional use authorization required for the project, weighing the developers' vision against the community's concerns. The outcome of this meeting could have lasting implications for the future of residential development in the area.