In a recent government meeting, plans for a new two-story accessory building behind a historic home were discussed, raising concerns about its compatibility with the surrounding historic district. The proposed structure, measuring approximately 29.4 feet in width and 25.2 feet in length, will feature a garage on the first floor and storage or an apartment on the second. The building's height is estimated to be around 28 feet, similar to that of the primary residence, which has sparked debate regarding its visual impact on the historic neighborhood.
The accessory building is designed to accommodate a handicapped van, necessitating the installation of two industrial-sized garage doors measuring 10 feet by 10 feet. While the homeowner has expressed a desire for these larger doors, concerns were raised about their aesthetic implications. Suggestions were made to modify the door design to create a more visually appealing appearance from the street.
Additionally, the meeting highlighted the importance of aligning the new structure with the architectural guidelines of the historic district. Recommendations included replacing small hopper windows with standard-sized windows to better match the fenestration patterns of existing buildings. The proposed entrance design, featuring garage doors facing Chester Street and a side pedestrian entry, was noted as being consistent with traditional garage access in the area.
The accessory building's placement is also under scrutiny, as it is set to be located approximately 30 feet behind the primary structure, making it highly visible from multiple angles. The meeting underscored the need for further drawings to assess the overall design and ensure it adheres to the district's guidelines, balancing the homeowner's needs with the preservation of the historic character of the neighborhood.