In a recent government meeting, the board discussed a proposal for significant alterations to a historic property located at 132 King Street, St. Augustine. The applicant, Albert Kroll, seeks to replace a window on the front facade with a three-quarter light door, aiming to enhance accessibility from a bedroom to the porch. This building, constructed between 1910 and 1914, is a contributing structure to the Modeling Company National Register Historic District.

During the meeting, staff presented their findings, indicating that the proposed changes could maintain the historic character of the building if executed properly. However, board members expressed concerns regarding the aesthetic implications of adding a third door to the already altered facade, which they felt could compromise the building's historic integrity. The existing facade features two doors and a pair of windows, which some members argued are essential to the building's character.

Kroll defended the proposal, citing safety concerns and the desire for a more functional layout for potential short-term rentals. He emphasized that the existing windows are in poor condition and need replacement, and he assured the board that the new door would be designed to match the existing doors in style.

Despite the applicant's arguments, several board members remained skeptical, highlighting the lack of visual representations of the proposed changes. They suggested that the applicant consider alternative solutions, such as creating a vestibule to maintain the current window structure while still providing access to the porch.

The discussion concluded without a definitive decision, as board members expressed the need for more detailed plans and drawings to visualize the proposed alterations. The board's focus remains on preserving the historic character of the building while accommodating the applicant's needs. Further deliberation is expected as the applicant revises the proposal to address the board's concerns.